2025 Transfer Portal

Additional thoughts on some WCC guys, transfers, etc…
While there have been a ton of WCC guys enter the portal there are some other interesting cases of guys who haven’t entered the portal and/or similar to Malik Thomas are senior who may be in position to petition for an extra year of eligibility…highlighting a few of the better players:

  • USF’s Nwedo Newbury. Injured early season and only played 11 games and his frosh and soph years only played 11 and 13 games, partly due to injury. Could get leniency for a med redshirt.
  • WSU’s Cedric Coward - listed as a senior but only played 6 games this year due to injury, should be an easy med redshirt. Plus spent a year at a JC, so he may be able to secure 2 more years of eligibility.
  • GU’s Steele Venters. Class of 2019, already in his 6th year but only listed as a junior and he was of course injured again. He theoretically could have 2 years of additional eligibility, thus spending 8 years at the college level. That said, after 2 serious injuries who knows if he can ever get on the court again.
  • Pepp’s Boubacar Coulibally- listed as a senior but only played 6 games for USC in 2021/22 and 11 games for Pepp last season…maybe another candidate for med redshirt???

Just a few examples.

1 Like

OSU’s Nate Kingz landed at Syracuse.
Portland’s Max Mackinnon to LSU.
LMU’s Will Johnston committed to Richmond.
GU’s Dusty Stromer to GCU.

Sorry if any of these are repeats.

An even better (which is to say, more ridiculous) example: the aforementioned Hunter Dickinson has apparently gotten a waiver to play a sixth year of college basketball (7 years of college in total). Dickinson has already fully played five seasons, appearing in at least 25 games each season and averaging ~25 minutes per game at his lowest point.

Dickinson is the classic guy whose value is at its max in college, so the incentive to stay in the game is obvious. But man is it bad for the sport. A guy like Dickinson getting a 7th year in college “just because” bums me out for the overall direction of all of this, but maybe we’re close to touching rock bottom before Congress intervenes with antitrust protections?

What was Dickinson’s argument for an extra year?

I imagine the NCAA legal team is weary from loss after loss after loss and has more or less given up on setting any guardrails.
And agree with you, while it may be good for individual older players, it is bad for college hoops as a whole and in particular for younger players who will get stuck sitting on the bench behind 7th year guys like Dickinson. At the end of the day there is a fixed amount of court time to go around. In the past those minutes were spread over 4 to 5 years or classes of players…now it is becoming 6 and even 7 years.

https://x.com/tiptonedits/status/1908245417256472586?s=46&t=PXTiTKoGV0aVfWCl4sMW5Q

Buckeye Nation not too excited out Tilly. This article said OSU recruited him- disgusting- hate the portal

Later Thursday afternoon, former Santa Clara center Christoph Tilly — a 7-foot tall, 240-pound center who was born in Germany but spent much of his childhood in Chile, transferred to Ohio State. He averaged 12.5 points, 4.9 rebounds, and 1.9 assists per game last season, playing for Herb Sendek at Santa Clara.

Ohio State’s pursuit of and commitment to Tilly is a complete 180 from last year’s transfer portal strategy. Last spring, Jake Diebler swung high for the uber-talented sophomores who didn’t perform as freshmen, and it blew up in his face.

Aaron Bradshaw fell marvelously short of expectations, and this week he entered the transfer portal once again looking for a fresh start elsewhere. Sean Stewart showed more promise than Bradshaw and the arrow is pointing up for the soon-to-be junior, but ultimately 5.7 points and 5.8 rebounds per game in 18.4 minutes per game did not meet the expectations that anyone had for the former McDonald’s All-American.

Tilly is 22 years old, and has one year of college basketball left. He scored 10 or more points 22 times last season, but only scored 20 points five times. He had at least five rebounds 15 times, but only grabbed 10 or more three times. He had three double-doubles sprinkled in, including a 17-point, 12-rebound performance against UAB in the NIT.

He also did that in just 23 minutes, which was not uncommon for Tilly at Santa Clara. Despite being a starter for the last two seasons, Tilly only averaged 20.1 minutes per game as a sophomore and 22.7 minutes per game as a junior. The Broncos went nine-deep all season long, with only one player averaging 30 minutes per game or more.

Tilly was not the best center in the transfer portal, nor was he the most athletic or the most exciting. He’s not exactly a dual threat big man, having only shot 32% from three-point range last season. He’s not a hound on the glass either, grabbing roughly five rebounds per game last year. But he is something that Ohio State desperately needs this year: consistent.

While fans would have loved to add a stud center who averages 20 points, 10 rebounds, and three blocks per game, those don’t grow on trees, and frankly a player with even half of those stats will make a huge difference for Ohio State.

Maye he’s a bit vanilla, but Tilly should provide the post presence this year that Ohio State so desperately needed last season.

The Buckeyes were 13th in the Big Ten in two-point field goal percentage last season (52.6%), mostly because their two-point shots were rarely by post players below the basket. More often, it was a contested jumper or floater by a guard, because defenses were so locked in on Thornton and John Mobley Jr.

If Ohio State had a viable starting center last year, opponents wouldn’t be able to ignore the paint and allow their defenders to cheat up towards the perimeter, where Thornton and Mobley were. The presence of a 7-footer who is actually an offensive threat should help with that.

Tilly shot 61.7% from two-point range last season and was an even better 63% at the rim. He didn’t draw a ton of fouls or shoot a ton of free throws, but when he did, he was a 77% free throw shooter, so he can make teams pay at the line if they foul him going to the rack. It’s not eye-popping, but he’s solid, and at 7-feet tall and 240 pounds, he’s not exactly a little fella.

What happened on Thursday isn’t going to knock anyone’s socks off, but the bottom line is that Ohio State got better yesterday. For a team that was probably one win away from making the NCAA Tournament last year, that’s all that matters.

Oregon State’s Damarco Minor is in the portal. That’s full bingo on Beavers starters transferring with eligibility remaining.

As a Wolverine you should be excited about Yaxel Lendeborg, who crushed SCU’s NIT hopes, heading to Ann Arbor

2 Likes

Yaxel should be declaring for the Draft…looked ready for the NBA to me.

3 Likes

He was a projected 2nd rounder. Maybe will make more $$$ wearing the maize & blue next season? Another college season to try and get into the 1st round?
But definitely agree that he can play in the NBA

1 Like

Finally, I tried to look at this. My back of the envelope math should really be taken as such, especially since my definition of “no eligibility remaining” seems quite different from the NCAA’s determination this year.

So there are 143 scholarship roster spots in the WCC for Men’s Basketball (11x13). As of this morning, I count 61 names in the portal, but at least 5-6 of those are walk-ons. Without actually counting the walk-ons, I’m going to assume there are about 55 actual scholarship players in the portal from the WCC.

Then I tried to count how many players should be out of eligibility (again, this is apparently not as static as I thought) and came up with 35 players who are just moving on the old fashioned way. This doesn’t include Thomas but would have at 10 am yesterday, so who knows how reliable that number is.

55 / (143-35) = .509 i.e. ~51% of players with eligibility remaining in the portal from the WCC

Yikes. Some reporting I saw today provides a little context. Because (a) the House settlement isn’t finalized but is expected to go into effect within a few weeks and (b) that settlement is likely to eliminate most NIL deals either legally or practically (will exist but only for a handful of players whose endorsement actually has brand value), many schools are effectively liquidating their entire NIL accounts right now. Revenue sharing is coming, and the NIL money is already in the bank but may not be usable by next season. So whatever is in there is getting thrown at players right now, leading to the huge surge in the portal.

Again, I wouldn’t bet on this exactly, but this might be the height of portal madness. By next season, it looks at least quite possible if not probable that the new revenue sharing era calms it down somewhat and, at the very least, creates some more transparency in the system.

But there won’t be a true end to portal madness until Congress gives the NCAA antitrust protection like the pro leagues have (allowing for collective bargaining, buy-outs, salary caps, etc.). And I don’t know if you’ve seen Congress these days, but I’m ummm not optimistic that’s coming anytime soon.

2 Likes

I really enjoy Michigan football but haven’t found myself able to get into Michigan basketball. I’m a mid-major guy through and through, I think. College football is all but a lost cause in terms of competitive parity, so rooting for my grad school alma mater doesn’t bother me. But Michigan is a big investor in the current system that’s an existential threat to Santa Clara basketball and college sports in general, so it’s harder for me to get excited about their success on the hardwood.

That said, Ohio State is the worst.

Thanks for the math and commentary. I read somewhere (sorry i cant pinpoint) that the House settlement wont be truly settled. Someone(s) is/are going to appeal the outcome on equity (Title IX?) grounds. So this may be far from over.

2 Likes

Here’s a lousy wake up call today. St. Mary’s advertising its success right in our face in the San Jose Mercury News….Congrats to them - they’re all in. Where are we?

Good for them. They earned it.

What would we advertise? The program that gave up the most 2nd-half double-digit leads in the past season? :rofl:

2 Likes

USF lands transfer David Fuchs from Rhode Island, 6-8, 225lb forward.
Two yrs of eligibility remaining. Fresh and soph year stats are about the same, career averages in ~21mins / game: 7.6pts, 7rebs, 58% FG, doesn’t shoot the 3 much. Appears to be a modest but reasonably efficient scorer and very good rebounder.

Verbal Commits | David Fuchs Stats, Offers, News, Highlights and more

Former Portland Pilot Austin Rapp committed to Wisconsin.
Big step up for him.

Rothstein reporting that Tyrone Riley is leaving the transfer portal and returning to USF

I don’t doubt Rothstein, but that would be an incredible if true. Riley reportedly met with Kentucky and had a $1 million+ offer from Arkansas. Taken with a grain of salt, but someone on the Hilltop must have found a lot of coins in the couch if they’re competing with those offers.

I really hope the SCU staff is cooking up something special with USF getting two decent transfers, a solid frosh commit, and their star freshman back all within 72 hours. The Dons looked on the brink for a minute but now roaring back to life.

Re the SMC ad – maybe I’m in the minority, but I think it’s kinda lame and smacks of some “please, please, please let us into the Pac-12” desperation. Don’t get me wrong, I’m totally jealous of the Gaels’ success. But they don’t give out state championships in college basketball, and the Tournament isn’t quite over yet. The SMC ad just reminds everyone that the Gaels didn’t make the Sweet 16 again, so they’re making a debatable claim to being the best in the state (ummm UCLA??).

It’s not quite a “Game On!” level of cringe, but I think it’s more in that direction that a projection of strength.

Edit: Just to show it’s not totally sour grapes motivating my analysis, I actually think this sort of ad would be effective at the beginning of the season when you’re trying to drive interest and tickets and antagonize your rivals a little. At the end of the season, when your team has exited the Tournament, it just looks lame. “Hey, maybe we are the Houston of the West” read in Keating’s voice, basically.

4 Likes